Astro 5: "Life in the Universe" - Spring '24

Our exams will all be on Canvas, except perhaps the Final Exam, which may be live in the classroom if that is your wish. We'll vote on whether to instead have on Canvas. That way you'll have more time to complete exams and still time to talk to me about any confusions.

The Course

No textbook required.
* Suggested supplementary books:
-- Rare Earth (Ward and Brownlee)
-- The Biological Universe (Arthur) - a different point of view

Schedule: Wednesday's 2:45-5:50pm.

My Lecture PowerPoints Lecture as PDF's

YouTube Videos on ET Life

Chapter 0 as online website
On Teaching

Extra Credit Opportunities

The Final Exam Study Guide

 

Other Course Resources


Key Points (link will come)
Evidence Confronts Astrology

Useful Links
Cabrillo Observatory
About Me
Videos: Scientists on the Big Questions
Supplementary Solar System YouTube Vids

Phil Plait's YouTubes "Crash Course" in Astronomy

An Astronomer's Life

MIRA's excellent set of Lecture notes on modern Astronomy

Useful Links from Cabrillo on
Life, Career, and other goodies as they arise


 

Instructor: Rick Nolthenius (...call me Rick!)

Office: 706a

Contact info

 

Office Hours in 706a
Mon: 11am-noon, 5:00-6:00pm

Tue: 6:30-7:30pm in Rm 705

Wed 11am-noon and 5:50-6:50pm

Fri 5-6pm at the Observatory

and otherwise by appointment

 

Welcome! Note that this is a transfer-level science course and we're here to understand our universe and the reasoning and techniques behind the science of astronomy at a level comparable to similar courses at UC or CSU (albeit without mathematical problem solving). In this course, we'll be looking at...
* The nature of science, scientific method, and how we acquire knowledge (chapter 0)
* the nature of life and the controversies that surround the question - just what IS life?
* Intelligent life: what is it? Is consciousness required? What might be the requirements for consciousness to arise?
* Key requirements for an environment suitable for long term life. Chief among these is a climate that is stable with fairly narrow ranges
* The SETI search
* Our first interstellar visitor: Oumuamua in 2017. What was it? Odd comet? or Alien spacecraft?
* How long term stable climate defines the habitability of a planet.
* Paleontologist Peter Ward's insights into mass exctinctions and his "Rare Earth" ideas
* The Drake Equation and prospects for intelligent life
* And additional topics


 

I have insightful thoughts on the subject of scientific method and the nature of clear thinking. We'll use my own "Chapter 0" for this area and it will be our first week of class lecture. Please also read my essay "On Teaching", which overlaps some material from Chapter 0 but addresses a slightly different issue.

 

What I'm here for: Encourage clear thinking, healthy skepticism (not the same as cynicism!), an appreciation for a scientific mindset, turn you on to the joys of discovery and your true connections to the cosmos.

 

Schedule and Lectures

This course is better described as "Topics in Life in the Universe", since we do not have any evidence of life on any other moon or planet than Earth, and we are only beginning to flesh out ideas on how life arose from the inanimate beginnings. As new discoveries are announced during the semester, they may be incorporated into our meetings. We have a good range of video lectures from seminars at universities and Nova PBS programs to add to our mix. Towards the end of the course, we'll do a detailed set of lectures on the Drake Equation and the modern version of the Drake Equation, and make the case for Earth being perhaps the only planet in the Galaxy which is home to intelligent life. Perhaps the most intriguing material will be a day spent showing my 120 slide Presentation on the fascinating object named Oumuamua, which swung through our solar system in 2017 and was the first object from another star system to visit our Solar System. We'll make the case for and against, it being an intelligently designed space craft..

I use powerpoint presentations most days. Here is the home page for the Astro 5 PowerPoints

Grades

Like all good exams, there's a mixture of easy, moderate, and harder questions. All will be multiple choice objective questions with firm answers.

 

* Quizzes: 70%. There will be 6 "lecture quizzes" covering lecture and textbook material (about 8-10 multiple choice questions each), and 3 "video quizzes" (~13-26 multiple choice's). The "lecture quizzes" are closed-book. On the videos you should definitely take notes, and you may use these notes and only these notes while taking the video quizzes. Your lowest 2 quizzes (including video quizzes) scores will automatically be dropped. If you miss two quizzes, then those will be the two low scores that are dropped from your scoring. For any additional missed quizzes, you take a 30%. There are no makeups. The average of your remaining quizzes will be your quiz score, and accounts for most of your course grade. Each question has equal weight, so that longer quizzes are more important. This is to your advantage, as students usually seem to do better on the video quizzes, which tend to be longer.

 

* Final Exam 30%: About 50 multiple choice questions on lecture/ text material only (not the videos). You'll have at least 3 hours to do both Quiz #6 and the Final Exam, totalling about 60 questions.

 

* Extra Credit! You can raise your final grade percentage by doing extra credit in several ways. See the separate Extra Credit page for more.

 

* CLASS PARTICIPATION: My computer will give a final numerical percentage score for you. Then, when I actually assign the letter grades at the end, I will look at how close you came to making the next higher grade and then remember how interested and involved you were during the lectures. It's like a bit of extra credit for "attitude". Of course, I'll never ever give you a lower grade than your scores indicate.

 

Important note: If you miss the final, here's what'll happen. If you've already got a good reputation with me for working hard and the other Astro 3 section's final still hasn't been given, you may sit in and take their exam (same text and course, but different questions... I can't let you take the same exam you missed, for security and fairness to those who were there). Unfortunately, that means a different final than your study guide was tailored for (but still the study guide for the other section is available to you above). If your class has the last final exam time so there is no chance to sit in on the other class's final, I will look at your average quiz grade, lower it by 1 grades, and assign that as your final exam grade. Or, if your grades are otherwise good and you let me know right away, I can give you an "incomplete".) Example; your average quiz score is a middle"B", but you miss the final. You will get a middle "C" score for your final... So, don't miss the final!

 

Grading Scale: Letter grades will be assigned from your total cumulative percentage as follows:

 

A......80% and above

B......70% - 79.99%

C......60% - 69.99%

D......50% - 59.99%

F......below 50%

Credit; 60% and above.

At the end of the semester my computer takes the weighted average of all your work, plus extra credit, and gives a final percentage out of a total possible 100%. Only then do I assign a letter grade. Write down your quiz scores as you go along so you can calculate what your grade would be at that moment. Please note that Canvas Quizzes has a limited ability for me to alter scores. I have my own grading rubric; sometimes I must throw out a quiz question, or it accidentally has 2 right answers (Canvas can't deal with more than 1 right answer to multiple choice questions). If your % score is different than what Canvas shows, I'll make that clear in communicating with you and the class. I expect the average course grade will be in the B range. That includes a lot of students with imperfect study habits. However, people of all kinds have all earned "A" grades when they come to lecture, do the reading, and ask questions about material they don't understand.

 

Exam Policies

In order to speed scoring and to sample a larger range of questions, I give only multiple choice quizzes/exams which you'll do on Canvas quizzes. Your lowest two scores will be dropped, and that may include missed quizzes, without affecting your grade. The dates of the quizzes are on the schedule above. It's possible we might have to delay a quiz if we fall too far behind, but I will never ever give a quiz BEFORE the stated time I put into the schedule.. Remember, I consider any exam you take, in principle, as a fair sample of your mastery. The only reason I drop two is to not penalize the occasional, tragic, legitimate miss. Beyond those two, a missed quiz is recorded as a 30%. Write down your scores and keep a running average so you'll know how you're doing. Just drop your lowest two exams, add up the total possible's, add up your number correct's, divide one into the other, compare to the scale above. Those used to rote factoid-ized learning may be surprised and find my exams will stress grasping the logical connections. But remember, I like to hear questions! I know some of this material is rather abstract and I don't expect everyone will get it the first time; but only YOU can identify what you don't understand. Don't let your shyness get the better of you! The more involvement and questions you put forth, the more fun I (and we) have.

 

* Dropping the class: It is the student's responsibility to drop a class. If you just stop showing up and don't tell anyone, you'll likely end up with an "NC" on your record. This has happened too many times. Don't let it happen to you!

--Last day to withdraw is (see schedule of classes)

--Last day to go for Pass/No Pass is (see schedule of classes)

Once the withdrawal cutoff has happened, there's nothing I can do to keep you from getting a grade for the class - Our dean says she will not sign grade changes to "W" for forgetful students.

 

* Pass/No Pass: The counselors can tell you if you can or should take this class Pass/No Pass. The purpose of Pass/No Pass is to allow students to take non-essential classes "for fun", without grade pressure. It's tempting to use it as an "out" to make sure you never get a D or F, but that ruins the value of grades in evaluating performance, hence they give the early deadline. So, you need to tell me by the deadline if you decide to go for Pass/No Pass.

 

How to Approach this Course

What will make for a good class? I do love teaching interested people about their universe. I like to try and figure out new ways to describe the workings of the planets, stars, and galaxies with down-to-earth analogies. I like listening to you and figure out how you think, how you reason, how you construct your interpretations. No matter how foolish the world may often be, the workings of the universe at large have a logic, a symmetry, and a harmony which is beautiful to all who open themselves to it. If you can think of our time together as your time to just be curious, to talk with me, and to discover, we'll have a great time.

 

The ideal class "esprit de corps" would be informal and conversational... more a discussion than a "lecture", but focused on science, clear thinking, and astronomy. In the Fall '20 CoVid era, while I still welcome conversation and impromptu question asking, my experience so far is that Zoom and Canvas don't make that very easy, what with the satellite delays, audio feedback from student's phones and computer mics, etc. I accept that that's going to be a bit of an inhibitor, but still welcome your impromptu feedback.

Added Attractions

 * Get practice learning the art of thinking like a scientist. Learn healthy skepticism, a respect for evidence, and sharpen your reasoning skills so you can debunk the pseudo-science types!

  * Purple Sucker Awards! For each quiz, those making a perfect score will earn a token of my esteem; (a bit of candy), and the accolades of the class.

  * It's not impossible that the Santa Cruz Astronomy Club, may hold star parties again before the end of the semester in which case they'll be held at Quail Hollow near Zyante.

 

**** Nolthenius-brand dry humor to lighten the proceedings!

 

Additional Resources and Links for You

The Science of Current Climate Change
Astrology and the Evidence
TeachAstronomy - a free online text and related materials (a work in progress - still the early stages of development).

My essay; On Teaching
TED: lectures from famous thinkers online

YouTube video interviews with Great Scientists on the Big Questions

YouTube Videos on Astrobiology and Life in the Galaxy

Solar system web visuals, videos, simulations
Free Online Science Programs and Documentaries (beware; quality is highly variable)

 

Students needing Special Accomodations
Students needing accommodations should inform the instructor. As required by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), accommodations are provided to insure equal access for students with verified disabilities. To determine if you qualify or need assistance with an accommodation, please contact ACCESSIBILITY SUPPORT CENTER (Formerly DSPS), Room 1073, (831) 479-6379.
NONDISCRIMINATION and ACCESSIBILITY notice: The District is committed to equal opportunity in educational programs, employment, and all access to institutional programs and activities. The District, and each individual who represents the District, shall provide access to its services, classes, and institutional programs and activities. The District, and each individual who represents the District, shall provide access to its services, classes, and programs without regard to national origin, religion, age, gender, gender identity, gender expression, race, or ethnicity, color, medical, condition, genetic information, ancestry, sexual orientation, marital status, physical or mental disability, pregnancy, or military and veteran status, or because he/she is perceived to have one or more of the foregoing characteristics, or based on association with a person or group with one or more of these actual or perceived characteristics.

 

Student Learner Outcomes

1. Identify the key requirements for a planet to harbor advanced life and how this differs significantly from the requirements for primitive life.

 

2. Describe the connection between greenhouse gas processes and parent star evolution and how strongly this limits life possibilities.

 

3. Calculate the approximate number of living and intelligent living planets in the Galaxy from evaluation of parameters in the Drake Equation, based on evolving understanding of planets beyond the Solar System.